York Mills Rental Comps & Market Trends
Access granular residential building comps, verified lease benchmarks, and real-time inventory for 19 tracked properties across York Mills, North York.
Active Rental Inventory
Listed and Tracked by FastScreen as of August 2026Current publicly listed rental units and asking prices across York Mills
Closed Leases
Transactions that closed in August 2026 across York Mills
York Mills Rental Rates by Unit Layout
Realized lease pricing, square footage, and pricing spreads across layout configurations based on transactions in August 2026.
York Mills Tracked Buildings & Lease Comps
Compare average realized rents, price per square foot ($/SF), active availability, and leasing velocity across tracked condo buildings in York Mills, North York.
| Action | |||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Hillside I 18 William Carson Cres | $3,100/mo | $3.30/SF | 2leases | 1unit | Comps |
Hillside II 28 William Carson Cres | $3,625/mo | $3.54/SF | 2leases | 0units | Comps |
Hillside III 38 William Carson Cres | $3,500/mo | $3.18/SF | 1lease | 1unit | Comps |
10 Old York Mills 10 Old York Mills Rd | $5,200/mo | $3.94/SF | 1lease | 1unit | Comps |
Kilgour Estate II 21 Burkebrook Pl | $4,300/mo | $4.53/SF | 1lease | 0units | Comps |
Kilgour Estate 20 Burkebrook Pl | $3,300/mo | $4.40/SF | 1lease | 0units | Comps |
Governor's Hill 3800 Yonge St | $3,750/mo | $3.41/SF | 1lease | 0units | Comps |
York Mills Mansions 75 York Mills Rd | $3,900/mo | $8.57/SF | 1lease | 0units | Comps |
One Post 1 Post Rd | $8,500/mo | $3.24/SF | 1lease | 0units | Comps |
265 Ridley 265 Ridley Blvd | — | — | 0leases | 0units | Comps |
Residences of Ridley Blvd II 268 Ridley Blvd | — | — | 0leases | 0units | Comps |
York Mills Place 3900 Yonge St | — | — | 0leases | 0units | Comps |
Governor's Hill II 3600 Yonge St | — | — | 0leases | 0units | Comps |
The Antiquary of York Mills 11 William Carson Cres | — | — | 0leases | 0units | Comps |
Residences of Ridley Blvd I 271 Ridley Blvd | — | — | 0leases | 0units | Comps |
Fifeshire Gardens 96 Fifeshire Rd | — | — | 0leases | 0units | Comps |
The Chedington I 1 Chedington Pl | — | — | 0leases | 0units | Comps |
The Chedington II 2 Chedington Pl | — | — | 0leases | 0units | Comps |
One Donwoods 1 Donwoods Dr | — | — | 0leases | 0units | Comps |
18 William Carson Cres
28 William Carson Cres
38 William Carson Cres
10 Old York Mills Rd
21 Burkebrook Pl
20 Burkebrook Pl
3800 Yonge St
75 York Mills Rd
1 Post Rd
265 Ridley Blvd
268 Ridley Blvd
3900 Yonge St
3600 Yonge St
11 William Carson Cres
271 Ridley Blvd
96 Fifeshire Rd
1 Chedington Pl
2 Chedington Pl
1 Donwoods Dr
Derived from verified closed lease contracts finalized during August 2026 across multi-residential buildings in York Mills.
Realized monthly lease price divided by interior living square footage (excluding external terraces and parking valuations).
Total executed lease agreements. In boutique buildings with fewer than 2 monthly leases, comps automatically expand to a 90-day rolling window to preserve statistical validity.
The duration from public MLS listing publication to final binding agreement. Active supply reflects current vacant or upcoming units available for rent.
York Mills Rental Market Dynamics & Local Yield Trends
Comprehensive Residential Market & Yield Overview for York Mills
York Mills is an established residential submarket within North York, comprising 19 tracked condominium and multi-family properties. The neighbourhood benefits from strong local demand, proximity to regional employment nodes, and accessible neighborhood commercial amenities.
Transportation throughout York Mills is anchored by municipal transit connections, primary arterial thoroughfares, and nearby regional highways, connecting residents efficiently across North York and the wider Greater Toronto Area.
The residential inventory in York Mills features a balanced mix of contemporary condominium developments and established multi-residential suites, offering versatile floor plans tailored to individuals, couples, and working professionals.
Submarket Pricing Density & Municipal Benchmark Spread
The realized average lease rate in York Mills is currently $4,375/month ($3.49/SF), with an average leasing velocity of 21 Days on Market. Compared to the overall North York municipal benchmark ($2,573/month), York Mills trades at a 70% price premium, reflecting local transit connectivity, tenant demand, and building amenity standards. Within the submarket, building-level lease rates range from Hillside I ($3,100/mo) to One Post ($8,500/mo).
Currently across York Mills's 19 tracked multi-family properties, there are 3 active rental listings with an average asking rent of $4,250/month ($3.61/SF). For closed transactions executed in August 2026, realized lease agreements averaged $4,375/month, representing real-world contract values negotiated between property owners and prospective tenants.
For Renters
Evaluate both verified closed lease comps and active asking prices across York Mills to pinpoint value. Units featuring included parking stalls and private balconies represent high-utility assets. With an average of 21 days on market, prepare pre-verified credit reports, proof of employment, and deposit drafts prior to viewings. Check building construction completion dates to confirm Ontario rent control guideline applicability.
For Landlords
Aligning initial asking rents with recent 30-day closed transactions rather than speculative active listings prevents extended vacancy periods and protects net operating income. At an average rent of $4,375/mo, each day of vacancy costs $146/day. Pricing your listing accurately to 30-day verified comps eliminates costly extended marketing periods and protects your annual net operating income.
For Realtors
Review building-level historical lease velocity and $/SF trends in York Mills to prepare comprehensive, defensible comparative market analyses for clients. Utilize granular building-level $/SF comps across York Mills's 19 properties when preparing client CMAs. Highlight transit walking times, parking inclusions, and balcony square footage to command premium tenant interest.
York Mills Rental Market & Leasing FAQs
Essential insights for tenants, property owners, and real estate professionals navigating York Mills, North York
Based on lease transactions tracked by FastScreen in August 2026 across 19 tracked condominium and apartment buildings in York Mills, realized rents by unit layout average:
- Studio / Bachelor:$2,975/mo($6.47/SF · 460 SF)+$1,225 vs North York avg
- 1-Bedroom:$3,225/mo($3.42/SF · 945 SF)+$1,115 vs North York avg
- 1-Bedroom + Den:$3,894/mo($6.08/SF · 640 SF)+$1,604 vs North York avg
- 2-Bedroom:$5,433/mo($3.65/SF · 1558 SF)+$2,603 vs North York avg
- 2-Bedroom + Den:$3,500/mo($3.18/SF · 1100 SF)+$412 vs North York avg
- 3-Bedroom+:$6,563/mo($5.56/SF · 1180 SF)+$2,703 vs North York avg
Overall market leasing across all unit layouts averaged $4,375/month ($3.49/SF) with an average of 21 Days on Market. Active rental listings currently average $4,250/month ($3.61/SF) for an average unit size of 1167 SF.
Explore Other North York Submarkets
Compare neighbourhood comps and rental rates for leased units across North York against York Mills